Friday, January 26, 2018

Do we even know what we assess when we assess learning?


‘It took me quite some time to get the little girl to let me know what was bothering her,’ said Prof. A. K. Sharma, the former Director of NCERT. The year was 2000 and he was telling me about an incident from a class 2 maths period in the model school in the NCERT campus. The teacher had just completed teaching children subtraction of two-digit numbers with ‘borrowing’, and he had found two children hesitating over the problems they had been given to solve.

The first, a girl, had made a ‘mistake’ as she had failed to borrow from the tens side. Being a grandfatherly and kindly figure, he was able to cajole the girl to speak up. Very softly, looking down and away from him all the while, she said, ‘We learnt in the moral science class that borrowing is bad.’

Reeling from this, he approached the other child, a boy, and discussed why he had not completed his work on the problem. After much exchange, the boy said, ‘But why should I borrow 1? I want to borrow 2.’


Taking part in a recent session on ‘error analysis’, I was reminded of Prof. Sharma’s advice to engage with children to understand their ‘errors’ rather than rely on their work on paper. In numerous assessment experiences since, I’ve seen children who are otherwise very competent falter because of an issue at home or a fight with a friend or because they are being bullied. In open-ended questions in language, teachers are hard put to identify if there really is an ‘error’ or if the child’s view is a valid, logical interpretation. (And asking only close-ended questions is hardly sufficient to understand children’s abilities.) It becomes even more difficult when it comes to children from marginalized backgrounds – as they encounter discrimination and even denigration (of their background, language or culture), they often resist by ‘not-learning’ or do not answer out of fear of being ‘disciplined’.

As the evaluation industry expands in the Indian context with more and more professionals taking in rigorous analysis of children’s responses and analyses of their ‘errors’, the tendency is to interpret these within the framework of the subject for which the test was conducted. But do we know what we really assess when we look closely at children’s responses? What if it’s not a maths or language issue but something else altogether?

22 comments:

Anonymous said...

Language and memory share a curious connection. Research has found that we aren’t able to describe our experiences in the early stages of our life before catching on the skills of a language even after we have acquired the words to do so. We tend to acquire language skills and the ability to memorize around the same age. http://www.language-school.hk/

Komal Gupta said...

Wow this post is very informative for Childern and her fathers In many schools and colleges Teacher failed to make the child learn but punishment to the child.but this is not good for teachers,and effects on students. vist here >>>>>>>mba colleges in up
top universities in up for masters in engineering

Monika Roy said...

Thank you for imparting such an informative content. I like the way you publish such an useful post which may help many needful. Visit here for more info >>>>>>best engineering universities in up
best mba colleges in up

Neha Tiwari said...

Thanks for sharing this great article! That is very interesting I love reading and And its most important for Every Students like this>>>>>>>>>fees for agriculture course in up
fee structure for d pharma colleges in up

Joya Khan said...

Fantastic articles is post by you in this blog. You give a nice thing. Thank you for such a nice article. Every word og this blog helps me to give detail to me
best management colleges in up
B.Tech. Civil Engineering University in UP
Top Journalism university in UP

Software Blogger SEO said...

Do you want to earn more money easily, here is the link of link shortener just click and see and start earning you will get bounus and more Earn directmoney -

Software Blogger SEO said...

Do you want to earn more money easily, here is the link of link shortener just click and see and start earning you will get bounus and more earn money-

Ambilms said...

I had no idea what a blog was or how to start one
LMS Education
New LMS

avviareeducations said...

Hello everyone,
Its article related to educational point so this content or website most important for person. thanks for sharing.

Best College for M.Sc Noida
Best M.Sc Courses Noida
Top management institute Noida
bba correspondence colleges in Noida
Best M.com Courses Noida
Best College for B.A. Noida
Best College for BJMC Noida
Best College for M.Sc (IT) Noida
Best B.B.A LL.B Courses Noida
Best B.PHARMA Courses Noida

M&G Immigration said...

Excellent post. It is very inspiring and informative. Thank you for sharing this.
Study Abroad Consultants in Mavelikara

College Janakari said...

Its very informative and interesting and useful for us. Please add some more details with the posts
And we are also provide best colleges list for medical, engineering, management etc.

Online Education Portal
Medical Colleges list in India
Engineering Colleges list in India
Management Colleges list in India

Research World said...

Excellent post. It is very inspiring and informative. Thank you for sharing this.
GATE Online Coaching in Kerala

Team Treasure Notes said...

AHSEC Class 12 English Syllabus 2023 | AHSEC HS 2nd Year English Syllabus | AHSEC Class 12 Syllabus

B-GHUD Academy said...

Great post. Thank you for sharing
IELTS Coaching Centre Kochi

Anonymous said...

IIBF JAIIB, CAIIB, BANK PROMOTION, CERTIFICATION EXAMS 2022 preparation and clear exam with IIBF ; best study material, latest syllabus, mock test, ePDF, important concept
IIBF ; CAIIB June 2022
IIBF ; CAIIB June 2022
https://learningsessions.in/
https://learningsessions.in/abm-exam-mock-test-study-material-syllabus-pattern-pdf-notes-2022/
https://learningsessions.in/bfm-exam-mock-test-study-material-syllabus-pattern-pdf-notes-2022/

Best Private University said...

Great post. Thank you for sharing. best university in Bhopal. Madhyanchal Professional University is located in Ratibad Village in Bhopal on an area of 70 acres surrounded by hills and water in a lush green environment.

Online Shiksha | Online Tuition Classes and Education Tips said...

This blog has some excellent information. I'd like to see more posts similar to this. Good luck with your future articles and postings, and keep up the good work. Visit our weblog on SSSi offers online service for class 10 English.

English is so crucial to every student's life that they all need to have a strong command of the language. English is often thought of as a class 10 subject that performs well. So, in order to master the exam and achieve amazing ratings, kids who wish to acquire a good grade in class 10 can concentrate on English. SSSi offers the greatest online lessons for class 10 English classes, therefore you may receive support from them in this situation.

Eclassopedia- Find all subject's online tutors from India said...

Are you looking for online tutor for students?

jazz said...

can i use CNC Fräse Metall in this process

Change consultancy said...

Change consultancy : Services for Organisations enables them to thrive in a world constantly changing by bringing inclusion to the forefront of what they do

vijay said...

Assessing learning is complex. It's not just about memorizing facts; it's about critical thinking, problem-solving, and applying knowledge. Understanding what we truly assess is essential for meaningful education.
best ICSE schools near lb Nagar Hyderabad

Davinder Bisht said...

Join BIPS, the best play school& Montessori in Patiala. Exceptional kindergarten experience. Admissions open! Call: 18001376668.